The Driving team has been testing the three types of car with electric power: a Toyota Auris Touring (hybrid, below), a Volkswagen Golf GTE (plug-in hybrid) and a Renault Zoe (pure-electric). Which will prove the most practical solution during the winter months for three full-time workers with young families?
- Model 2017 Toyota Auris Hybrid Excel Touring Sports
- Motor 1,798cc four-cylinder petrol
- Power 91bhp @ 5,200rpm
- Torque 105lb ft @ 4,000rpm
- Electric motor power 80bhp (60kW)
- Electric motor torque 153Ib ft
- Maximum combined power 134bhp
- Top speed (NEDC lab test) 112mph
- 0-62mph 0-62mph 13.5sec
- Fuel consumption 70.6mpg
- CO2 emissions 92g/km
- Road tax£110 for first year; £130 a year for next five years
- Benefit in kind tax 17%; £909 or £1,818 (2017/2018; 20% or 40% tax payer)
- Price from £26,905
- Price with options£28,950
- Options fitted Leather seats (£950); Metallic paint – white pearl (£545); Panoramic roof (£550)
- Test period November, 2017 to April, 2018
- Starting mileage 1,374 miles
- November 29, 2017: Introducing the Auris Hybrid
- January 2, 2018: What’s it like to drive a hybrid?
- January 18, 2018: Comparing the company car tax costs of petrol, diesel and hybrid
November 29, 2017: Introducing the Auris Hybrid
You know that feeling when a friend says, with a certain degree of smugness, “Hate to say I told you so”? Well, that friend is Toyota. And while it may seem hard to believe, it has been warning of the perils of diesel for two decades.
In 1997, Toyota launched the Prius. It was the first petrol-electric hybrid car to be built and sold in meaningful numbers. Then, ‘meaningful’ meant 1,000 a month.
Its mission was to persuade more motorists to adopt ‘clean’ hybrid technology. The company claimed that its emissions of hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxide were just 10% of the levels demanded by Japanese regulations. Its CO2 emissions were also said to be significantly reduced compared with conventional petrol cars.
The Japanese car maker waxed lyrical about its creation: “Engineers closed their eyes and imagined a car that would change everything. It would do less harm to the environment by significantly reducing noise and emissions, and would maximise fuel economy beyond that of most vehicles. Now Toyota has realised that vision and you can park the future in your driveway.”
Today, my driveway has a Toyota Auris parked on it. It uses the same sort of hybrid powertrain that the Prius introduced, 20 years ago.
The original idea behind a ‘green’ hybrid system still stands today; namely, that it should be no different to driving a conventional car with an automatic gearbox.
That means it asks nothing different of the driver. So there’s no need for anyone to get their hands dirty, and plug cables into power sockets at home or public charging points.
Instead, the car’s petrol engine and electric motor work in harmony, and onboard technologies, such as regenerative braking, help keep the electric motor’s battery charged at all times. All you have to do is fill it with petrol from time to time.
Because it isn’t a diesel, it is increasingly seen as a socially acceptable everyday family car. And the road tax and company car tax are competitive. All of which partly explains why 10 million of drivers have bought a hybrid Toyota.
The leap from 12,000 sales in that first year, to more than 10 million today, suggests Toyota’s engineers had the clearest glimpse of the future of any car company.
The Auris Hybrid Touring Sports is Toyota’s equivalent to diesel-powered versions of the Ford Focus estate, Kia cee’d Sportswagon and Volkswagen Golf estate. It’s built in Britain, at Toyota’s plant in Burnaston, Derby, and costs from £22,085 with hybrid power.
This one on extended test comes in top-of-the-range Excel trim, which lifts the price to £26,905. With optional leather seats, metallic paint (white pearl) and a panoramic glass roof (which doesn’t open) the cost ends up at £28,950. In its first year of road tax, this hybrid costs £110, then £130 a year for the following five.
The serious savings start if you’re a company car driver. This Auris Hybrid attracts benefit in kind tax of 17%, versus 25% for the broadly equivalent VW Golf estate 2.0 TDI GT 150 DSG. It means a 40% tax payer would have to hand over £1,818 for the Toyota, during the 2017/2018 tax year, whereas the VW would be £2,714.
At such an early stage of proceedings, there’s little point looking into the real-world fuel economy of the hybrid system. Toyota promises a combined economy figure of 70mpg, but it will take some practice to get it anywhere near that. We live in the Kentish countryside, and the twisting, rolling nature of local roads is going to test to the limit this car’s ability to make fuel go as far as possible.
First impressions are of a very quiet car that has steering and suspension tuned for comfort. Performance is best described as lethargic. The petrol tank is on the small side (just 45 litres; a Golf diesel estate holds 50 litres), but perhaps this is in order to create the vast, 675-litre boot – which shames plenty of estate cars from the class above. Rest assured, it will be put to good use; with three children and two dogs, this estate car will be worked hard.
Aside from the real-world fuel economy and associated running costs, the burning question for many drivers is whether Toyota’s hybrid system is as easy to live with and nice to drive as a diesel-powered family car.
I’ll be answering that, and more besides, in further updates on this page.
Want to ask a question? Contact me via Twitter:
January 2, 2018: What’s it like to drive a hybrid?
I have been getting to grips with the box of tricks hiding under the bonnet of the Auris Touring Sports, grandly named the Toyota Hybrid Synergy Drive system.
In some ways, driving a hybrid car is no different from driving a ‘normal’ petrol or diesel model, but in terms of the engineering it’s a lot more complex.
Of course, it has two power sources: an engine and an electric motor. For the benefit of those unfamiliar with Toyota’s hybrid system, it is what’s known as a full hybrid. This means that both powers ources can work together or independently, such as running solely on electric power at low speeds.
In the Auris’ case, it comprises a 1.8-litre, naturally aspirated petrol engine which has just 98bhp and a 650-volt, 80bhp (60kW) electric motor. These work in harmony with a power control unit, generator and special power split device that uses a planetary gear set in place of a conventional gearbox to smoothly distribute power between the engine, motor and generator.
The good thing about this system is that there is no need to get your hands dirty with power cables, as there is with the Renault Zoe and Volkswagen Golf GTE we are running. The charge for the electric motor’s battery is maintained by the petrol engine or when the Auris is coasting or braking. So all the driver has to do is fill the rather small, 45-litre fuel tank with petrol and the car takes care of the rest.
The default driving mode is ‘normal’, but you can also select EV mode (electric only, up to a certain speed), Eco mode (dulled throttle, less effective air conditioning, etc.) or PWR mode (which makes the car more eager to respond).
I mostly leave it in the default running mode, but often switch the gear lever to the ‘B’ setting, which increases the level of power regenerated for the battery when you lift off the accelerator pedal. And I do my level best to keep the needle for the power display (a hybrid’s equivalent of a rev counter) hovering within the green Eco band, and have the electric-only running mode operating wherever possible.
The car will often start and move away using just the electric motor, which never fails to spook anyone that’s not been in a hybrid or electric car before. Under light throttle loads, this ‘EV’ mode can be continued at town driving speeds, assuming the battery is sufficiently charged.
When the petrol engine lends a hand, it’s as near as dammit a seamless process. And it needs to lend a hand a lot. We live in a hilly part of the Kent countryside, so the petrol engine and electric motor often have to combine forces to get things moving.
And therein lies the Auris Hybrid’s Achilles’ heel. It feels pretty sluggish when trying to build speed. Unlike a diesel car – even Toyota’s own Auris 1.6 D-4D – the hybrid system is lacking in torque (the grunt that gets a car moving).
Switching to the more spirited ‘PWR mode’ improves responsiveness, but in general this doesn’t feel like a car with much get-up-and-go.
Happily, the fuel economy has been hovering around the 50mpg mark. Initially, it was averaging 53mpg, before taking a noticeable dive during the sub-zero temperatures, to around 43mpg, before settling at 49mpg – where it remains, for now.
And let’s not forget that unlike a diesel, there’s no waiting for glow plugs (in older models), no unpleasant rattle from under the bonnet and the emissions – 92g/km of CO2 – are better than an equivalent diesel’s.
On longer, main road trips, that lack of torque continues to annoy. But the complicated planetary gearbox does a good job of working away seamlessly in the background as it juggles the hybrid system’s power sources and energy regeneration.
So far, the only problem encountered lies with the power steering. When parking, and switching between reverse and drive, the steering can weight up noticeably, and at one point it got so heavy for a second that I could barely turn it. It’s as though the electric power system is sometimes caught napping.
It should also be noted that the Auris is pleasingly quiet, both in terms of noise from the engine, road and wind. And with supple suspension that has clearly been tuned for comfort, this is a remarkably relaxing car to drive over long distances.
However, it is not a car for a spirited drive when the rest of the family aren’t aboard. But that probably suits the majority of hybrid buyers just fine.
Want to ask a question? Contact me via Twitter:
January 18, 2018: Comparing the company car tax costs of petrol, diesel and hybrid
Many hybrid-powered cars are chosen by company car drivers. These are the motorists who are handed a car by their employer – either to go about their job or as a perk that’s part of their benefits package.
The reason these drivers opt for a hybrid is that the tax – Benefit in Kind (BIK) – is calculated according to the car’s value and its CO2 emissions. So generally, if you can have a car that’s broadly the same price as a petrol or diesel model, but emits less CO2, it will be less draining on the monthly household budget.
It’s partly why hybrid-powered Toyota and Lexus models have proved so popular. If there’s one thing most drivers care more about than doing their bit for the environment, it’s doing their bit to reduce their bills.
Switching from diesel to hybrid could save drivers £1,810 in company car tax
To put this into meaningful perspective, a company car driver who took on a new diesel-powered version of the Auris Touring Sports in Design trim level, starting last year and running it for three years, would pay a total of £3,676 in BIK tax. And that’s as a 20% tax payer. A 40% tax payer would pay £7,352. Ouch.
Switch to a hybrid-powered model in Design trim and despite having a higher list price, there’s a lot less tax to pay, because its CO2 emissions are 92g/km, compared with 110g/km for the diesel.
Over the same three-year period, the hybrid would cost £2,771 (20% tax payer) or £5,542 (40% tax payer), saving £905 or £1,810 respectively.
For what it’s worth, a petrol-powered 1.2T Design with an automatic gearbox and CO2 emissions of 122g/km would result in BIK bills of £3,507 or £7,013.
It shouldn’t come as a great surprise, then, to see that half of all Toyotas sold in Western Europe last year were hybrid. Some models in Toyota showrooms, such as the new C-HR crossover, aren’t even offered with the choice of a diesel engine.
The Japanese car maker bet big on hybrid, reasoning it would be required to replace diesel if increasingly stringent emissions targets were to be met. It says that hybrid petrol cars emit up to 90% less nitrogen oxides (NOx) than diesels. Last year, sales of diesel cars in Britain fell by 17%; Toyota’s bet appears to be paying off.
Want to ask a question? Contact me via Twitter: